Skip to content

Amazon Prime’s Day Out

After much fanfare, July 15th kicked off as Prime Day, resulting in massive dealsoutages and the birth of a holiday in its own right.

Before Prime Day became a bigger shopping event than Cyber Monday, Amazon’s team was scratching its head a decade ago. The challenge thrown by Jeff Bezos was to increase customer loyalty to Amazon.

Two months after the problem-solving session in December 2004, Amazon unveiled Prime. Prime provided access to 2-day delivery for an unlimited number of orders, for $79 annually.

Prime has proved to be a consumer honeypot, growing from 0 to 10M from 2005-13 and 10x in just 5 years. Bezos is his fantastic shareholder letter this year revealed Prime had crossed 100M subscribers globally.

Prime has clearly become the arrowhead of Amazon’s consumer growth. While Prime did solve the customer loyalty increase, it also cleverly removed a massive growth obstacle.

That customer obstacle, which Amazon identified early on, was shipping fees.

In his excellent blog piece on Invisible Asymptotes, an early Amazon employee Eugene Wei identified this as Amazon’s growth ceiling. The rationale is quite clever – people hate paying for shipping, to the point of being irrational.

This irrationality is so strong, it makes customers avoid purchasing even discounted products. To solve for this problem, Amazon bundled shipping fees (partially) upfront.

That bundle is nothing but Prime.

It is no wonder that most consumers quote free shipping as the reason for purchasing Prime. The “free” shipping is recovered through the margin of products it sells, customer’s sensitivity to price reduces for Prime “fulfilled” products.

It is also no wonder that Amazon hiked its Prime subscription to $119, and it’s getting ever closer to recovering fulfilment fees in its entirety.

That brings us to the question of Prime Day, that we recently participated in as Indian (or global) consumers.

Why would Amazon give such steep deals on Amazon Prime Day and barely break even/lose money on their products?

This is because Prime Day’s strategy is not product-focused, but customer-focused.

It all boils down to the line “Deals exclusively for Prime members”. Prime Day is nothing but a potent customer acquisition strategy for high-quality (profitable) customers. 

Prime members are found to spend twice as much as “normal” shoppers (ergo high-quality customers). This occurs due to yet another clever perception management strategy where Amazon has made delivery “free” by actually charging for Prime upfront.

As a customer, I am now “committed” to spend till I recover my Prime membership. People hate paying for delivery, so Amazon calls it Prime – and I spend more!

The total lifetime spend of a Prime member (lifetime value) is expected to far exceed the “Prime Day discount” (actually customer acquisition cost) during Prime Day. Amazon Prime customers spend roughly $600 a year and Amazon may make ~20% as margin ($120).

Thus, up to $120 of discount, Amazon would still be profitable on a customer basis. Users would sign up for far less. Prime Day is actually an incredibly profitable long-term strategy.

It is not a new strategy, though.

Alibaba has popularized Single’s Day shopping to such a large extent, 2017 crossed $25Bn in sales – 6x Amazon on Prime Day. Nevertheless, it is an important customer acquisition strategy – especially for the Indian market.

Amazon and most large internet companies are saturating in their domestic markets. As I had analyzed earlier, the acquisition of PillPack and Whole Foods expands the Prime wheelhouse to increase per customer spend in the US.

Further combating of saturation will happen by acquiring new users in India, where there are at least 300 million urban consumers. India’s demographic dividend ensures it is a market of the future, and Amazon is out to acquire them.

Prime Day saw 35% of its sign-ups from small towns, which shows you why there was a silent roll out of the small ticket size 129 INR subscription. With Walmart acquiring Flipkart, the fight for the Indian consumer only intensifies. Amazon is digging deeper to lock in the Indian consumer.

The hope is the Amazon India’s website also crashes someday, due to unprecedented demand.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
3 years ago

What about the multitude of amazon prime subscriptions handed out free to customers, bundled with recharge plans by telecom giants like Airtel, or Smart TV moguls or Smartphone manufacturers, (albeit the offer is a one time 1-year subscription, but I believe the volume of enrollment is often quite large via this channel).

Sagar Tripathi
Sagar Tripathi
3 years ago
Reply to  Kriti

I am not sure of this , but what I can make out of this is that these charges are further paid by the telecom giants or smartphone manufacturers in form of specialized schemes. For example Oppo might sell its newly launched phone exclusively on Amazon for limited time period . this will further help Amazon to acquire larger customer base. And thus can even out its charges.

Rajesh Bhatia
Rajesh Bhatia
3 years ago

As per my not much knowledge of Amazon API (cloud), I can make 99.9% surety that Amazon India’s website will never crash 🙂

A programmer

Last edited 3 years ago by Rajesh Bhatia
Sagar Tripathi
Sagar Tripathi
3 years ago

I think that we are looking at this case only partially. We have taken into account delivery charges, discounted price of products, but what about some additional features that Amazon is providing like Amazon prime OTT , music platform. Al these features are free on prime membership. How do they maintain profits inspite of this?