Sep 15, 2024

Can $1B Porter Transport the Future of Indian Logistics?

Earlier this year, Porter entered the esteemed club of India’s unicorn startups by raising an internal round that valued the company at upwards of $1B.

Igniting Dreams

Pranav Goel spent his early days in Delhi and later moved to Gujarat. 

The change broadened his cultural perspective at a young age. Like many aspiring students, he set his sights on the prestigious IITs and soon found himself navigating the bustling streets of Kota. It was here that he first crossed paths with Vikas Choudhary.

Meanwhile, across Talwandi and Vigyaan Nagar, Uttam Digga had also arrived in Kota to prepare for the IIT entrance exams after completing his 12th grade in Bikaner.

Pranav and Uttam eventually became classmates at IIT Kharagpur, where they spent the next five years bonding and developing a strong friendship. 

After graduation, both ventured into the financial sector but soon found their conversations gravitating toward startups, notably how Uber revolutionised passenger mobility by using technology to unlock efficiencies in the cab industry.

Eager to do something more meaningful, they began brainstorming business ideas. They initially explored passenger mobility but found the space already overcrowded with competitors. 

They also considered the car repair industry but were discouraged by the low margins. Even healthcare entered the discussion but did not quite click.

Then, one evening, on their way back from the office, they spotted a truck—specifically a light commercial vehicle (LCV)—which sparked a new interest. They realized the logistics market bore similarities to Uber’s model but served a different use case.

Motivated, they went into the field, researching and speaking with over 500 truck drivers and small-to-medium businesses (SMBs). 

The insights they gathered were invaluable. Drivers and SMBs could often be found in clusters, making accessing potential users and understanding their pain points easier.

Their findings were eye-opening. The logistics market was highly inefficient, with significant opportunities to leverage technology.

Even more striking was that truck drivers were not respected in society. If they could build a solution that improved the livelihoods of these drivers, they could create long-term relationships and make a lasting impact.

Convinced they had found their calling, Pranav and Uttam were ready to leave their jobs and dedicate themselves to solving this problem.

In August 2014, Porter was born.

Revving up the Engine

Pranav and Uttam divided responsibilities early on. 

Pranav handled operations from the office, managing calls and logistics. Uttam hit the field, onboarding LCV drivers and offering prospects a 20% discount for booking their next delivery through Porter.

Within a few days, they secured their first booking. Porter's intra-city LCV platform was ready to take off.

To scale the business, they needed someone to spearhead the technology side. That is when Pranav brought in his friend from Kota, Vikas, as the third co-founder.

With a founding team in place and a minimum viable product running smoothly, thanks to calls and Google Sheets as their initial solution. Porter was ready to grow. 

They even kept a few talented individuals on standby, knowing they would soon need more hands to tackle the logistics industry's complexity.

It was 2014, in the pre-Housing.com bust era, and venture capital was flowing for talented teams building for large markets. By the end of the year, Porter raised a $500K seed round, giving them the resources to build a solid team and turn their idea into reality.

2015 brought a new level of excitement. The market was booming, and funding was pouring into sectors like food delivery, hyperlocal delivery, and logistics. 

Shows like TVF Pitchers were inspiring a wave of new entrepreneurs, and for the first time, India’s nascent startup ecosystem felt like a bubble.

Porter was riding the wave, too. Four months after its seed round, it secured $5.5M in Series A funding.

Flush with cash, the young founders got ambitious. They expanded into inter-city logistics and began building solutions for enterprises.

It seemed like they were ready to fly with enormous money. 

However, these moves veered from their core mission of solving intra-city logistics for small and medium businesses (SMBs) using LCVs. It was a case of growing too fast, too soon, and they quickly realized they’d made a strategic mistake.

Instead of taking off, the business almost collapsed under its expectations. Close to having run out of money, the company had to take a big step. 

By 2016, they refocused on execution, doubling down on increasing the fleet supply available through the Porter app. They began to figure out how actually to make money. 

Piling the Truckload

Porter’s name implied it made money simply by transporting goods from point A to B.

More goods meant more trips, which should naturally lead to higher revenue. However, the real strength of Porter’s business model lay in how efficiently it utilized its trucks during these trips. 

It was worth studying India’s logistics market dynamics to understand why this was a differentiator. 90% of the market, excluding air freight, was unorganized and highly fragmented.

For decades, players operated on a scheduled appointment model in the offline era. Whoever needed freight services called up a few truckers to check for availability and rates.

After a handful of calls, they would invariably choose the provider with the lowest price. Could another operator offer a better proposition? Perhaps, but the customer would never know.

Were there other clients who could share a shipment and reduce costs for everyone involved? Very likely, but the logistics provider had no way to find them.

Demand was not visible to supply, and supply had no way to gauge demand. As a result, trucks often returned empty after deliveries. With no other option, truckers would factor the cost of the empty return trip into the original fare, increasing prices.

The logistics ecosystem was siloed and riddled with inefficiencies. Enter Porter with its on-demand, Uber for logistics model.

 Its pure-play matchmaking system significantly improved the likelihood of securing return trips.

 A trucker who could rely on a second or even third trip in a day was willing to offer more competitive rates. This, in turn, attracted customers, mainly SMBs, who quickly saw the benefits.

Porter gave them real-time access to spot availability of small trucks for intra-city logistics and full transparency in pricing, reducing their overall costs.

 Pranav, Uttam, and Vikas had successfully unlocked a powerful advantage in a fiercely competitive, price-sensitive market.

Shifting Gears

By 2017, Porter had expanded to 5 cities - Mumbai, Delhi, Bangalore, Chennai, and Hyderabad.

 It had onboarded 1500 vehicles and was handling nearly 3000 trips daily. Building a two-sided marketplace with strong network effects required relentless execution and careful management of drivers and customers.

Porter prioritized its commitment to driver partners as the business grew. It introduced same-day payouts, a first in the industry.

Porter expanded its fleet to improve delivery efficiency, adding 500 three-wheelers to its operations.

To further elevate the customer experience, Porter focused on ensuring timely arrivals and deliveries. It utilized GPS tracking through its app, providing real-time updates to customers and reallocating drivers in case of delays.

It further addressed inefficiencies at loading and unloading stations by introducing per-minute charges and incentivizing punctuality among customers.

These optimizations paid off. Porter ensured that 80% of its drivers secured return-trip orders, boosting their earnings by 20-30%.

As a result, Porter amassed 50,000 monthly active customers and 10,000 drivers and surpassed 3 million lifetime bookings.

The quiet progress attracted attention from the right quarters. In February 2018, the Mahindra Group struck a deal to merge its logistics arm, SmartShift, with Porter.

Mahindra committed to invest INR 65 Cr in the merged entity to become a significant minority shareholder. Porter’s momentum seemed unstoppable.

Then, the Hong Kong-based logistics giant Lalamove entered India, armed with deep expertise from developed markets and substantial financial backing.

Lalamove made its mark by launching a two-wheeler logistics service, an offering that most players—including Porter—lacked. This surprise move shook the market.

Lalamove lured SMBs with cashback incentives to gain a foothold quickly, sparking fierce market share competition. Just as the battle intensified, Porter got a stroke of divine luck.

In a sweeping move, the Indian government banned Lalamove as part of a crackdown on Chinese apps following escalating border tensions between the two nations.

Porter seized the opportunity to reclaim its lost customers and strengthen its market position.

Horn Not OK Please

India's logistics market was immense, at $200B, and it grew at a CAGR of 10% annually. 

Road logistics alone accounted for 55% ($110B) of the overall market, with the rest spread across rail, shipping, air transport, and warehousing. Approximately 85% of the road logistics market was tied to inter-city transport, while the remaining 15% covered intra-city deliveries.

The market was dominated by small fleet operators, who owned fewer than five trucks each and represented 67% of road transport operators, controlling more than half of the trucks on Indian roads.

However, the industry’s unorganized and fragmented nature posed significant challenges. A lack of aggregation meant that 35% of transport vehicles carried less than full truckloads, and operators often struggled to find goods for return trips.

Low asset utilization squeezed margins.

Reliance on regional brokers also diminished customers’ bargaining power, while indirect costs such as theft and damages ran high.

As a result, logistics costs in India were disproportionately high, consuming an estimated 14% of the country’s GDP. In comparison, other BRICS nations spent only 10-11%, the U.S. 9.5%, and Germany just 8%.

The logistics sector was ripe for disruption.

In response, the decade following 2010 saw an influx of startups tackling the industry's inefficiencies. Funding for the sector surged from $161M in 2013 to almost $3B by 2018.

Startups approached these challenges from different angles.

Founded in 2015, Blackbuck specialised in B2B intercity full-truckload transportation as a digital intermediary between customers and truck operators. It later expanded to offer various value-added services, including load management, payments, fuel and FASTag solutions and financing.

Rivigo, founded in 2014, took a different path. It bet on market consolidation by owning its own fleet and operating a freight aggregation platform. 

It introduced a relay trucking model, in which drivers switched at designated pit stops, improving asset utilization and cutting delivery times.

Porter, however, played a different game. It focused on intra-city and last-mile transportation, catering to both businesses and consumers. Using a heavy data-driven and digital approach, Porter tackled several pain points in the intra-city logistics space.

Porter's algorithm boosted driver earnings and passed cost savings on to customers.

On the B2B front, Porter capitalized on the booming e-commerce economy, onboarding giants like Amazon and Flipkart as clients. E-commerce logistics, which comprised 16% of the logistics industry in 2018, was projected to rise to 28% by 2025.

By carving out a niche in intra-city transport, Porter was well on its way to dominating this segment of India’s massive logistics market.

Roadblocks and New Routes

In 2020, COVID-19 brought with it a host of challenges. 

The nationwide lockdown was seen as an existential threat to SMBs, which made up the bulk of Porter’s customer base. Doubts arose over whether Porter could survive the crisis. As the physical world came to a standstill, the biggest losers would be those who moved it around.

However, investor support remained strong. In April 2020, Porter secured a $15M Series D round, providing the company with a much-needed financial lifeline during the turbulent period.

Unexpectedly, demand for intra-city logistics surged during the pandemic as consumers turned to ordering essentials like medicines and groceries. Seizing the opportunity and diversifying its customer base, Porter launched a range of new services.

Recognizing the growing need for last-mile logistics for consumer-to-consumer and B2C deliveries, Porter introduced two-wheeler delivery services, entering the same space as competitors such as Dunzo and Swiggy Genie.

Additionally, Porter launched a 'Packers & Movers' service to help people relocate amidst the scarcity of local providers during lockdown. By 2022, this service accounted for 5% of Porter’s overall revenue.

To further broaden its reach, Porter introduced ‘Porter for Enterprise,’ targeting B2B consignments with both on-demand and contract-based delivery services. Businesses could access vehicles within 5-10 minutes, track multiple deliveries nationwide, enable cashless payments, and receive digital proof of delivery.

Over time, Porter for Enterprise secured partnerships with notable brands like GoMechanic for delivering spare parts and Berger Paints for expedited delivery of paint orders to small businesses within two hours.

The lifting of the lockdown and the resurgence of SMBs further fueled Porter for Enterprise, contributing nearly 10% of Porter’s revenue by 2022.

Far from being an existential threat, the COVID-induced lockdown significantly boosted the intra-city logistics sector. Consumer and business adoption of app-based, last-mile delivery solutions accelerated much faster than it would have otherwise.

Putting Pedal to the Metal

Conventional logistics businesses were riddled with inefficiencies. 

Rising fuel costs, low capacity utilization, idle vehicle time, and inefficient route planning all contributed to higher costs for end customers. Porter set out to redefine the logistics industry to achieve profitability while maintaining efficiency.

Traditional logistics companies attempted to maximize asset utilization by consolidating orders, which often led to significant delays—a major customer pain point. 

Porter took a different approach, leveraging analytics to solve this problem. It built a proprietary data science and predictive analytics engine capable of processing data from fulfilled orders, generating insights for effective fleet deployment. 

Porter achieved optimal fleet utilization and order consolidation without unnecessary delays by analysing real-time data gathered through vehicle sensors. 

Vehicle load matching and demand forecasting allowed Porter to position resources where they were most needed, reducing turnaround times.

Amid rising fuel costs, Porter faced the challenge of cutting transportation expenses while maintaining efficiency. Porter minimised transportation costs through cutting-edge route optimization technologies without affecting delivery times.

As a result, Porter emerged as the low-cost logistics carrier across India.

With operational efficiencies in place, Porter shifted its focus to customer segmentation to boost margins. It identified business logistics as a massive opportunity and began offering differentiated services to B2B customers.

While B2C customers continued to receive conventional pick-and-drop services, Porter introduced truck rentals for B2B clients, significantly increasing the average revenue per customer.

Going Full Throttle

In 2022, Porter fortified its intra-city logistics capabilities.

Porter partnered with major FMCG and D2C brands, playing a crucial role in the logistics transformation of companies like ITC and Marico. 

As both giants expanded their direct-to-consumer models - ITC increased its stake in Mother Sparsh and Marico acquired multiple D2C startups - Porter became their trusted last-mile delivery partner, ensuring efficient and timely shipments.

Leading D2C brands like Lenskart, boAt, and MamaEarth also turned to Porter to scale their logistics operations amidst rising demand. These partnerships allowed Porter to solidify its position as a critical enabler of fast and reliable last-mile deliveries, seamlessly optimizing logistics across industries.

In 2023, Porter expanded into the packaging and movers vertical, targeting business and individual customers. The new offering included courier services for shipping goods, exceptionally high-volume, bulky items, using Porter’s reliable and extensive fleet. 

Leveraging existing resources, Porter quickly gained traction with its affordable and accessible packaging solutions, capturing additional market share and boosting revenue.

This expansion into complementary services further entrenched Porter’s position in the B2C space as a comprehensive, tech-driven logistics provider. As urban demand for faster, more dependable deliveries continued to rise, Porter’s asset-light, technology-first approach was ideally suited to meet this growing need.

While this diversification broadened Porter’s scope, it also increased operational complexity. 

However, these initiatives paid off with a remarkable revenue surge from INR 848 Cr in FY22 to INR 1,754 Cr in FY23. Yet, the company’s rapid growth came with growing pains; losses swelled by 43%, reaching INR 175 Cr over the same period.

Porter’s scale and customer satisfaction strategy remained steadfast despite these financial setbacks. Its driver-partners experienced a 30% increase in earnings compared to traditional models, while customers enjoyed up to 20% reductions in logistics costs. This win-win model kept Porter on its growth trajectory.

By the end of 2023, Porter had expanded to 15 cities, with a user base exceeding five million customers and a fleet of over 200,000 drivers. As it looked toward the future, Porter was poised to continue refining its logistics solutions, working toward profitability and long-term growth.

Porter’s evolution from a niche player in intra-city logistics to a multi-faceted provider marked a significant chapter in its journey. The company was now ready to build on its success further and continue revolutionizing the logistics landscape in India.

Road to Glory

Porter’s ambitions are expanding beyond domestic borders. 

While the company continues to explore opportunities in new Indian cities, international markets are now firmly on the radar. This growth trajectory has already placed Porter in unicorn territory, with an internal funding round in May 2024 catapulting its valuation to over $1B.

A Dunzo shaped void had appeared in the Indian intra-city market, as the company struggled to raise and survive. Porter jumped into the picture overnight, ramping up its two-wheeler logistics, almost reminiscent of Lalamove many years ago. 

Today, Porter is a dominant force in India’s intra-city logistics sector. Operating across 19 cities, it boasts a growing fleet serving over 8 million customers and 5,000 enterprise clients, including major players in e-commerce and FMCG.

Porter’s journey has evolved well beyond simple transportation services. The company now offers integrated warehousing solutions and last-mile delivery, transforming from a logistics marketplace into a comprehensive, end-to-end logistics provider. 

This vast network enables Porter to deliver on-demand logistics for businesses of all sizes while driving operational efficiencies for more giant corporations.

Amid discussions of a potential IPO, Porter is signalling its readiness for the next leap in its journey. The company is targeting 60% growth this year and is pursuing operational profitability by the end of 2024. 

To achieve this, Porter must continue leveraging technology to scale its operations into a full-spectrum logistics service. Expansion across geographies is essential, as is refining its platform to offer more efficient, scalable solutions for businesses and consumers.

The numbers show movement towards profitability, as revenue is almost 2x while losses are halved. Astonishingly, the company has nearly 20x in the last five years. 

As Porter grows, its success will hinge on its ability to maintain a flexible, asset-light business model while using technology to optimize logistics operations. In an increasingly competitive landscape, Porter’s focus on scalability through innovation will be key to sustaining its edge.

From its rapid rise to becoming a logistics powerhouse, Porter’s journey is marked by clear growth. With technology-driven expansion and the prospect of an IPO, Porter is well-positioned to cement its leadership in end-to-end logistics—both in India and beyond.

In the buzz of e-commerce, Porter is the quiet builder who has built a large-scale sustainable unicorn that could dominate the market.

Writing Team: Nikhil, Abhinay, Mazin, Shreyas, Vishal and Aviral Design Team: Abhinav and Mazin

Subscribe

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on what's happening in the Indian startup ecosystem

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

© 2024 ajvc Fund. Fund Manager: Founders Compass Ventures LLP. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on what's happening in the Indian startup ecosystem

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

© 2024 ajvc Fund. Fund Manager: Founders Compass Ventures LLP. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on what's happening in the Indian startup ecosystem

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

© 2024 ajvc Fund. Fund Manager: Founders Compass Ventures LLP. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on what's happening in the Indian startup ecosystem

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

© 2024 ajvc Fund. Fund Manager: Founders Compass Ventures LLP. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on what's happening in the Indian startup ecosystem

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

© 2024 ajvc Fund. Fund Manager: Founders Compass Ventures LLP. All rights reserved.